Is Your Business Idea Good Enough? 

Conjuring up business ideas can be an exciting undertaking. However, the thrill of imagining your product or service out in the world can easily cloud your judgment. Critically evaluating your idea and the target market is important before diving in. That’s why the question “Is my business idea good enough?” becomes so crucial.

Indeed, a business idea can make or break your business.  Validating your idea before investing significant time and money is essential. Interestingly, this isn’t just a pitfall for first-time entrepreneurs. Even established brands have made the mistake of rushing a launch without proper validation.

‘A Navara with Mascara’: A Case Study

Take Mercedes-Benz, for instance. One of the world’s leading luxury car brands launched the Mercedes-Benz X-Class pickup truck in South Africa (July 2017). This vehicle, built on a Nissan Navara chassis, aimed to capitalise on the growing premium pickup truck segment. However, due to low demand, the company was forced to stop production.

Source: Top Gear

Why the Low Demand? The Importance of Market Validation

Charlen Raymond¹ attributes the X-Class’s failure to two key factors. Firstly, part-sharing with the Nissan Navara clashed with its premium vehicle branding. Imagine buying a Nissan Navara with three-pointed stars! Secondly, the price point significantly exceeded competitors, including the Navara itself. This price disparity earned the X-Class the nickname “a Navara with mascara.”

Feedback is the lifeblood of your business idea.

Alexander Zulu

Perhaps, if Daimler, Mercedes-Benz’s parent company, had conducted sufficient market validation to see if the X-Class could carve out a niche in the luxury pickup segment (especially considering Ford’s previous struggles), they would have discovered consumers’ unwillingness to pay a premium for a rebranded Navara. This case study underscores the critical importance of market validation. Your idea might look stellar to you, but will the market think so, too?

How to Validate Your Business Ideas

Catherine Cote² of Harvard Business School defines market validation as “the process of determining if there’s a need for your product in your target market.” She further emphasises that “validating your business idea can enable you to reasonably predict whether people will buy your product or service and whether your business will be profitable.” It’s a simple yet fundamental step towards business success. The figure below confirms that product-market fit, or offering a product that the market does not need, accounts for the biggest reason why startups fail.

Source: OpenVC

Here’s a breakdown of the validation process

1. Document Your Idea

Recognise that at this stage, you’re primarily working with assumptions, especially if your idea is new. You don’t have hard facts, only assumptions. Launching based solely on assumptions can significantly decrease your chances of success.


2. Test Your Assumptions

Sell a minimum viable product (MVP) of your product or service to your target customer segment. Utilise your network of family, friends, or colleagues to gauge the validity of your assumptions.


3. Gather Feedback

Feedback is the lifeblood of your business idea. Talk to your potential customers and understand their true needs. Are you offering them something they actually want, or are you trying to “sell beans to a market that wants rice”? Shaun Gold³ offers a valuable insight: “[People] Liking your idea is not the same as buying your product. People may want to be supportive or simply be enthusiastic to help, but that doesn’t translate to guaranteed sales.”


4. Analyse Your Findings

Once you’ve sold your MVP and gathered customer feedback, it’s time for a critical analysis. If the results are satisfactory and confirm your initial goals, leverage the feedback to refine your product or service and launch with confidence. Congratulations, you have a viable business! However, if the results are less than ideal, it might be prudent to reconsider your venture. Moving forward without a strong foundation significantly diminishes your chances of success.


Remember, numerous validation methods exist. The optimal approach depends on the specific product or service you’re launching and the target market you’re aiming for. Regardless of the chosen method, the ultimate goal is to determine whether your business idea warrants a significant investment of your time and resources.

Read our How To Generate Side Hustle Ideas

Sources 

1. https://www.news24.com/life/here-are-three-major-reasons-why-the-mercedes-benz-x-class-failed-20200202-2
2. online.hbs.edu/blog/post/market-validation


3. https://openvc.app/blog/how-to-validate-your-startup-idea-6-methods-explained

• About
• Latest Posts

Alexander Zulu

Alexander Zulu translates complex business topics into clear, actionable content. He empowers businesses with his diverse experience – a decade in education, crafting copy for major brands (MTN Zambia, South Africa, Liberia and Nigeria, and Airtel Zambia), and corporate communication (ILO). He has written video documentary scripts for Zambia Construction News, Kingsland City, UNFPA, and others and further demonstrates his commitment to his community through his work with Woodlands Baptist Church in Lusaka, where he has authored Bible study guides for many years for the church. He has a Master's in Economic Policy Management, further strengthening his business acumen. He enjoys writing on startups, economics and small business management.


Latest posts by Alexander Zulu (see all)

• 13 Life Lessons I Learnt as a Teacher - July 23, 2024
• 13 Life Lessons I Learnt as a Teacher - July 22, 2024
• 13 Life Lessons I Learnt as a Teacher - July 21, 2024